Now in its twelfth year, Class 46 is dedicated to European trade mark law and practice. This weblog is written by a team of enthusiasts who want to spread the word and share their thoughts with others.
Click here subscribe for free.
Who we all are...
Greece: The Communication Review Board touches upon trade dress infringement
The Greek Communication Review Board (CRB) has entered the territory of
trade dress infringement via review of advertising material. In its decision No. 4911/2011, just before the
advent of the new year, it held that the appearance in advertising material/communications of various
types of the butter product ‘HORIO SOFT (unsalted, salted and light) created a
likelihood of confusion and took unfair advantage of the repute of the LURPAK butter trade
dress for the respective product types. In particular, the CRB held that HORIO’s
main trade dress elements, namely (i) the shape, (ii) a ‘wave’ device on
the upper and side part of the product and (iii) the colors red, blue,
ciel for each type of product respectively, were similar to those of the LURPAK
butter and could create consumer confusion (unfortiunately pics of HORIO disputed products aare not available). Moreover, the said similarities
entailed misappropriation of LURPAK’s reputation. It is interesting to note
that CRB’s know-how on ad strategy allowed it to disregarded the differences on the products’
word elements (something that courts are not always willing to do) to arrive at
its ruling. What the decision also confirms is that approximation of distinctive elements of a product's line always creates passing off suspicions (though this blogger is not sure whether the LURPAK butter's shape is distinctive).
The CRB’s willingness to rule on the case is quite useful
for brand owners as it allows them to make use of the CRB’s ultra-speedy
process to tackle trade dress infringement. Though not formally enforceable and
unable to substitute the value of a court judgment, the CRB’s decision is respected
and complied with by the advertising industry. Accordingly, for trade dress
infringement, the CRB can provide an efficient alternative dispute resolution
forum or, even, form part o of a wider litigation strategy, encompassing both ‘classic’
legal action and informal dispute settlement procedures.
Tags: Greece, Commincation Review Board, advertising, trade dress, passing off, product get up, Lurpak, Horio, Arla, Minerva,



Perm-A-Link: https://www.marques.org/blogs/class46?XID=BHA2703
24 January 2012 @ 17.57
For the completion of presentation of above CRB's ruling, it should be noted that the Board unanimously rejected the main request of ARLA to have the broadcasting of tv ads of MINERVA re HORIO product banned, resp. withdrawn. Furthermore, CRB did not order any prompt change of HORIO's trade dress, a measure that in the practice of CRB is usually ordered to be effected within 1-2 days and be controlled by same shortly afterwards in terms of compliance. CRB's rather ambiguous finding mentions passing-off "suspicions" that might be caused cumulatively - not alternatively - by all three elements mentioned in the commented report. But as the above blogger correctly questioned re one of said elements, is the shape of LURPAK's trade dress/packaging, within which butter is marketed, really original in terms of trademark law? Chr. Vayanos Kostopoulos