Log in


Now in its twelfth year, Class 46 is dedicated to European trade mark law and practice. This weblog is written by a team of enthusiasts who want to spread the word and share their thoughts with others.

Want to receive Class 46 by email?
Click here subscribe for free.

Who we all are...
Anthonia Ghalamkarizadeh
Birgit Clark
Blog Administrator
Christian Tenkhoff
Fidel Porcuna
Gino Van Roeyen
Markku Tuominen
Niamh Hall
Nikos Prentoulis
Stefan Schröter
Tomasz Rychlicki
Yvonne Onomor
France: The Supreme Court on genericide in the MECCANO case

Genericide was at the heart of the dispute reported by this blog's long-standing friend (and past member) Frederic Glaize. Writes Frederic:


In France, article L.714-6 (a) of the Intellectual Property Code transposes article 12(2)(a) of the 89/104 Directive (which became article 20(a) of the 2015/2436 Directive). According to the English text of the Directive:

“A trade mark shall be liable to revocation if, after the date on which it was registered:
(a)        as a result of acts or inactivity of the proprietor, it has become the common name in the trade for a product or service in respect of which it is registered;”

TM owners will often prove aggressive in order to prevent the revocation of their marks for such ground.

On March 1st, 2017, the Commercial Division of the French Court of Cassation delivered a judgment which may weaken trade marks used as ordinary substantives, as a type of antonomasia. The principle established by the French Supreme Court could make it more difficult to address such uses which go beyond the control of TM owners.

The case revolved around alleged infringement of the MECCANO trademark - a trademark used for (mainly children) construction sets and the facts are basically simple. The liability of the publisher of the weekly news magazine “Le Point” was confirmed, on appeal stage, because of the magazine's repeated use of "the registered trademark Meccano to form a composite word in a title or as a name of the common language in the text of various articles".

According to the appelate judgment of 21 October 2014, which was challenged before the Supreme Court, the publisher of Le Point had “used the word "meccano" as a common word in journalistic language, and that it conceptualized a sign, which constituted a mark registered for games, so as to extend it to the designation of all kinds of architectural building or assembly systems, without ever indicating in any way that it is a registered trademark".












The Court of Cassation held that "the use of a sign registered as a trade mark is not unlawful  unless it is capable of causing a degeneration of that mark". It added that the appellate court did not provide a legal basis for its decision "as it did not characterize how that use as a metaphor, which did not in this case refer to the designation of goods or services, contributes to such degeneration ".

The Supreme Court struck down the appeal judgment and the case was therefore sent back to appeal (before different judges) so that the facts may now be considered in the light of this principle.

Judgment No. 271 of 1 March 2017 (15-13.071),Société d’exploitation de l’hebdomadaire Le Point / société Meccano

Thank you Frederic!

Posted by: Nikos Prentoulis @ 08.59
Tags: France, Supreme Court, Cour de Cassation, MECCANO, genericide, Le Point,
Sharing on Social Media? Use the link below...
Perm-A-Link: https://www.marques.org/blogs/class46?XID=BHA4484
Reader Comments: 0
Post a Comment

MARQUES does not guarantee the accuracy of the information in this blog. The views are those of the individual contributors and do not necessarily reflect those of MARQUES. Seek professional advice before action on any information included here.

The Class 46 Archive








+44 (0)116 2747355
+44 (0)116 2747365

Unit Q, Troon Way Business Centre
Humberstone Lane, Leicester


Ingrid de Groot
Internal Relations Officer
Alessandra Romeo
External Relations Officer
James Nurton
Newsletter Editor
Robert Harrison

Signup for our blogs.
Headlines delivered to your inbox