Log in

CLASS 46


Now in its twelfth year, Class 46 is dedicated to European trade mark law and practice. This weblog is written by a team of enthusiasts who want to spread the word and share their thoughts with others.

Want to receive Class 46 by email?
Click here subscribe for free.

Who we all are...
Anthonia Ghalamkarizadeh
Birgit Clark
Blog Administrator
Christian Tenkhoff
Fidel Porcuna
Gino Van Roeyen
Markku Tuominen
Niamh Hall
Nikos Prentoulis
Stefan Schröter
Tomasz Rychlicki
Yvonne Onomor
THURSDAY, 13 JUNE 2013
Stokke stumbles in Danish 3D chair case

Since the early 1970s the Norwegian company Stokke has been manufacturing and marketing high chairs named TRIPP TRAPP, designed by Peter Opsvik. Previous Danish Supreme Court decisions had found that the chair enjoyed copyright protection as a work of applied art. Since 2004 its chair had also been registered as a 3D trade mark in Denmark. 

These earlier cases concerned high chairs which Stokke considered to be confusingly similar to its own chairs. In infringement proceedings Stokke had obtained interim injunctions against marketing of the defendants’ chairs.

In all these cases the Maritime and Commercial Court -- Denmark's first instance the trial court -- had found for the defendants and thus dismissed the claim that the defendants' chairs were confusingly similar to Stokke’s.

In the most recent cases, Stokke AS and Peter Opsvik v Jysk A/S, Schou Company A/S and Jan Bøgh, Maritime and Commercial Court June 4th, 2013, cases V-127-10, V-75-11 and V-9-12, the Court stated that there was no doubt that Stokke’s chair was protected as copyright and as a3D trade mark. The Court further stated that the Supreme Court, in a decision going back to 2001, had established that the characteristic by the TRIPP TRAPP chair is known and defined are in part the straight lines and the very austere form, in part the use of the “L-form” for the side rails and the horizontal legs.

With regard to one of the chairs (named Steve, depicted left) the majority of the judges found that the characteristic of the TRIPP TRAPP chair which also appears in the Steve chair is the constructive idea which is for free use, whereas the L-shape and the horizontal legs were not repeated but rather formed an upturned “Y” and that there were other differences. The majority of judges consequently found that the Steve chair was sufficiently free from the characteristics of the TRIPP TRAPP chair for it not to constitute copyright infringement. The fact that the TRIPP TRAPP chair was registered as a 3D trade mark could not lead to another result as there was no close imitation.

As to another of the chairs all judges (right), the Court stated the same arguments as above and added that, even though there were constructive likenesses between the chairs, these likenesses were functional and thereby did not change the conclusion that there was no close imitation.

The judgments are interesting as the Danish market for high chairs had for quite a few years been more or less distorted due to the fact that Stokke had been successful in several court decisions in pursuing competitors which were marketing high chairs which, in the perception of the informed user, could not be mistaken for being TRIPP TRAPP chairs.

Source: Mads Marstrand-Jorgensen, MAQS Law Firm, Copenhagen, Denmark. Christina Wiesner, who joined MAQS as a partner at the beginning of May, represented Jysk in these proceedings.

Posted by: Blog Administrator @ 22.22
Tags: Denmark, trade mark infringement, 3D trade marks,
Sharing on Social Media? Use the link below...
Perm-A-Link: https://www.marques.org/blogs/class46?XID=BHA3258
Reader Comments: 0
Post a Comment


MARQUES does not guarantee the accuracy of the information in this blog. The views are those of the individual contributors and do not necessarily reflect those of MARQUES. Seek professional advice before action on any information included here.


The Class 46 Archive






 

 

 

 

 

 


CONTACT

info@marques.org
+44 (0)116 2747355
+44 (0)116 2747365
POST ADDRESS

Unit Q, Troon Way Business Centre
Humberstone Lane, Leicester
LE4 9HA

EMAIL

Ingrid de Groot
Internal Relations Officer
ingrid.de.groot@marques.org
Alessandra Romeo
External Relations Officer
aromeo@marques.org
James Nurton
Newsletter Editor
editor@marques.org
Robert Harrison
Webmaster
robertharrison@marques.org
BLOGS

Signup for our blogs.
Headlines delivered to your inbox