Now in its twelfth year, Class 46 is dedicated to European trade mark law and practice. This weblog is written by a team of enthusiasts who want to spread the word and share their thoughts with others.
WEDNESDAY, 2 JANUARY 2013
Choo Choo trouble hits Polish kindergartens
The Polish entrepreneur Przedszkola Pomaranczowa Ciuchcia
A. Slawek sp. jawna from Warsaw, the owner of the word-figurative trade mark
pomaranczowa ciuchcia przedszkola R-247390 ("orange choo-choo kindergartens"),
sued another entrepreneur based in Minsk Mazowiecki who runs kindergartens as
its business activity under the name
Wesola ciuchacia ("Jolly
The District Court in Siedlce acknowledged that the plaintiff had the right to a complex trade mark (a word-figurative) which included the word "ciuchcia" a.k.a. "choo-choo" -- but declined to grant a preliminary
injunction on the ground that a ban would block the use of such word for any other business, which would hamper
the proper functioning of the market and could lead to the monopolization of
this word by one company.
The Appellate Court in Lublin in its judgment case file
I ACz 1156/12 dismissed the complaint filed by A. Slawek. Thatcourt held that
the company cannot extend the right of protection for the word mark orange choo-choo to the mere word choo-choo
in order to prevent others to use it in their company names. The right
of protection included the sufficiently distinguishable words orange choo-choo -- but the word
choo-choo itself, according to
the court, was not distinctive. Although these rights are in force throughout
the whole territory of the Republic of Poland, the risk of misleading
recipients of kindergarten services is limited because both entrepreneurs are
operating in very different areas -- Warsaw and Minsk Mazowiecki. The risk of confusion between the names orange choo-choo and
jolly choo-choo is also minimized
by establishing the entity that is responsible for running kindergartens, the
scope of education and educational services, human resources services and the
method of financing.
This post was written by Class 46 team member Tomasz Rychlicki and posted on his behalf by Jeremy Phillips
MARQUES does not guarantee the accuracy of the information in this blog. The views are those of the individual contributors and do not necessarily reflect those of MARQUES. Seek professional advice before action on any information included here.