Issue 76
  April 2017
Contents:
 

Luxury brands discussed in Hong Kong

>  
 

Your Hague questions answered

>  
 

The MARQUES Brexit Task Force

>  
 

Field Notes from the Outer Borders: Duff Beer

>  
 

In memoriam Wubbo de Boer

>  
 

Find out about MARQUES events

>  
 

MARQUES Media Roundup

>  
 

World IP Day marked around the globe

>  
 

WIPO and EUIPO in Barcelona

>  
 

Latest news from EUIPO

>  
 
Disclaimer:
The views expressed by contributors to this newsletter are their own and do not necessarily reflect the policy and/or opinions of MARQUES and/or its membership.  Information is published only as a guide and not as a comprehensive authority on any of the subjects covered.  While every effort has been made to ensure the information given is accurate and not misleading neither MARQUES nor the contributors can accept any responsibility for any loss or liability perceived to have arisen from the use or application of any such information or for errors and omissions.  Readers are strongly advised to follow up articles of interest with quoted sources and specialist advisors.
 

PO Box 10212
Leicester
LE41 9HG
United Kingdom
T: +44 116 274 7355
F: +44 116 274 7365
E: info@marques.org

Luxury brands discussed in Hong Kong

 

 

About 80 people attended the second MARQUES Luxury Brands Symposium, which was held in Hong Kong in March

Read More >>

Your Hague questions answered

 

 

MARQUES held the first of a series of events on the Hague System in Munich on 25th April 2017

Read More >>

The MARQUES Brexit Task Force

 

 

The MARQUES Brexit Task Force will identify and represent the key issues for brand owners as the UK prepares to leave the EU

Read More >>

Field Notes from the Outer Borders: Duff Beer

In the latest report from the IP Emerging Issues Team on unusual trade marks from around the globe, Thomas Raab looks at the emergence of a fictional brand into the real world


Homer Simpson, the main protagonist of the animated TV series 'The Simpsons', often spends his evenings enjoying an ice cold 'Duff Beer'.

The brand has become so famous that Time magazine included it in a list of the 18 most influential fictitious companies of all time.


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Although 20th Century Fox, the holder of the rights in 'The Simpsons', has numerous trade mark registrations in relation to DUFF, its creator, Matt Groening, had - due to the youthful age of many 'Simpsons' fans - refused to use or license Duff as a trade mark for beer. Others have tried to step into the gap and capitalise on the fame of the brand in relation to beer itself. 

In 1999 a German brewery applied to register the following logo as a trade mark in Germany:


 

 

 

 

 

DE39901100

Fox opposed the registration. As they did not own any trade mark rights for Duff Beer for class 32 in the EU, Fox asserted that Duff Beer was a notorious trade mark in Germany. That attempt failed as they were unable to prove that Duff Beer was in fact well-known among German consumers.

Initially, however, the German mark was not used as registered and a red label, much closer to the fictional Duff brand, was adopted.

A competing German brewery, Duff Beer UG, itself marketing another Duff beer using a logo similar to the fictional brand, submitted a cancellation application for lack of use. The German Federal Court of Justice (BGH) had to decide whether the use of Duff Beer in the form of a different logo constituted genuine use of the registered trade mark. The claimant asserted that the label used was more similar to the Duff Beer label from the TV series than the registered mark and so consumers, knowing the fictional Duff Beer from 'The Simpsons', would pay attention not only to the word Duff but also to the colour and design of the label and assume that the product was official merchandise. As a result, the distinctive character of the sign actually used was different from the registered trade mark and so did not qualify as genuine, right-preserving use.

The Court disagreed and ruled that the registered trade mark was essentially characterised by the lettering 'Duff Beer', which was used. Reasonably well-informed and observant beer consumers (presumably still on their first or second beer?) were primarily interested in the brand name rather than the shape and colour of the label, especially since various beers from the same brewery were typically offered under differently designed labels. The court further ruled that the reputation of the fictional 'Duff Beer' was not to be taken into account. What counted was the beer drinkers’ perspective rather than the view of consumers who were fans of the TV series 'The Simpsons'.

This meant there were two businesses in Germany selling competing Duff Beer products, neither of which were licensed by Fox.

Duff Beer UG’s logo

This case highlights the problems of trade mark proprietors in the sphere of merchandising. The image and reputation of a fictitious product or brand are at risk in the real world. To this day, the owner of the German mark Duff BEER has profited from Homer Simpson’s passion for 'Duff Beer'.

Fox’s attempts to protect the Duff brand continue – it appears to have reached an accommodation with Duff Beer UG, whose trade mark applications were transferred to Fox, and an application to register the German Duff BEER logo as an EUTM (008820763) is still under appeal. No doubt in part to help with its efforts, as reported by The Daily Telegraph, Fox finally announced that an officially licensed Duff beer would be launched, in Chile, last year, with plans to introduce it in Europe in the near future.

 

 

 

Thomas Raab is a member of the IP Emerging Issues Team and a partner of Taylor Wessing in Germany

 

 

 

In memoriam Wubbo de Boer

 


It is with great sadness that we report that the former President of the Office for Harmonization in the Internal Market (now EUIPO), Wubbo de Boer, passed away on the 20th April at the age of 68

Read More >>

Find out about MARQUES events

 

MARQUES Media Roundup

Check the MARQUES events page for the latest news about upcoming conferences and seminars, and for material from archived events

 

Sign up to receive posts on the MARQUES Class 46 and Class 99 blogs and follow MARQUES on social media

Read More >>   Read More >>

World IP Day marked around the globe

 

 

 

Francis Gurry of WIPO, Frank Salzgeber of the European Space Agence and Christopher Dodd of the MPAA were among those to post messages marking World IP Day on 26th April

Read More >>

WIPO and EUIPO in Barcelona

 

Latest news from EUIPO

WIPO and EUIPO will both be taking part in the INTA Annual Meeting in Barcelona, Spain from 20th to 24th May. Here's how you can engage with them

 

MARQUES is pleased to share information on the TM5, ID5 meetings, the European Cooperation Projects - Working Groups and the Case Law Laboratory on 12th June with members

Read More >>   Read More >>

Unsubscribe:
You can unsubscribe from this emailing list or change the frequency and type of information you receive from MARQUES at anytime by logging into the MARQUES website and clicking on the Preferences tab in the My Profile section of the My Account page.  Alternatively you can reply to this email with the subject 'NewsChannel - Unsubscribe' to be removed from this mailing list.