Login | Join Us | Contact Us | Search
 
 
 

 
 
  About Us   Press         Conferences   Members   Teams       Publications   Class 46     Position Papers   FAQs        Links     

Class 46 - for your European trade mark news
 

Now in its sixth year, Class 46  is dedicated to European trade mark law and practice.  This weblog is written by a team of enthusiasts who want to spread the word and share their thoughts with others.
 
  WEDNESDAY, 2 DECEMBER 2009
VOLVO dissolves SOLVO

Volvo Trademark Holding AB prevails in its appeal against the OHIM's dismissal of its opposition against the registration of the figurative mark "solvo" (depicted above) in Classes 9, 39 and 42 of the Nice Agreement. Both OHIM and the Board of Appeal had dismissed the opposition because the trade marks VOLVO and "solvo" (fig.) were not similar.

The CFI - sorry, General Court - disagreed. The two trade marks were at least phonetically similar. The Board of Appeal was therefore required to carry out a global assessment of the likelihood of confusion, which it failed to do. 

Volvo also prevailed with its second plea, claiming a violation of art. 8(5) of Regulation No 40/94 (protection of marks with a reputation). The Court notes that no likelihood of confusion is necessary to prevail under art. 8(5), a mere link between the younger mark and the mark with a reputation suffices. Since the Board of Appeal's incorrect assessment of lack of similarity between the two marks led it to conclude that no link was established, it misapplied art. 8(5).

Decision annuled.

 

Posted by: Mark Schweizer @ 14.22 
Tags: General Court, CFI, relative grounds of refusal, opposition, mark with reputation,

 

   0 comments:    Post a comment

 
 

Search Class 46
Search:

Who we all are...

Birgit Clark
Edith Van den Eede
Fidel Porcuna
Frédéric Glaize
Gino Van Roeyen
Jeremy Phillips
Kathrin Vowinckel
Laetitia Lagarde
Mark Schweizer
Markku Tuominen
Niamh Hall
Nikos Prentoulis
Pedro Malaquias
Robert Börner
Tomasz Rychlicki

Receive Class 46 by email
3256 readers now receive the Class 46 weblog by email circular. Why don't you?

To subscribe, just type your email address in the box below, then click the 'Subscribe' button.
email:

Receive Class 46 by RSS Feed
515 readers now receive the Class 46 weblog via an RSS reader.

Subscribe in a reader


The Class 46 archive


+ 2013
+ 2012
+ 2011
+ 2010
- 2009
     - December (44)
Spain - Court donates fakes to an NGO.
Greece - "skodo" creates a link with SKODA and not in a nice manners says the Greek Communication Review Board
SNOWSPORT
Russia: burgerking.RU does not belong to the famous burger chain
Spain – Want to recover your domain name? Do not go to Court.
An interesting article on IP, private international law and contributory infringmement cases
Latest ETMR now published
Christmas magic from the German Federal Patent Court: "Weihnachts-Zauber“
Can counterfeits enhance brand loyalty?
The battle of TSGs
Greece - Careful with health claims for children food products, says the Greek Communication Review Board
Italy scores three more PDOs
OHIM, WIPO sign Understanding on Classification Synergies
Latest batch of geographical indications approved
Russia: pledging stars
Advert for a “Christmassy deal”? Only if you pay 300,000 roubles first...
Ukrainian Higher Economic Court denies Ferrero’s claim on Raffaello trade mark infringement
PDO inspection costs "too high" for HÖLLEN SPRUDEL
The beer name no-one wants to protect
Spain - A branding miracle: from bullring to shop windows.
Lavazza to Nespresso: we were in heaven first
Liechtenstein signs up for Singapore
Not yet effortless, but at least a bit more paperless
New logo for Euro 2012
General Court: opposition and revocation proceedings are independent of each other
New practice notice on evidential value of UK correspondence
Consumer error need not be proved in criminal proceedings for online sales, says Barcelona appeal court
ICANN saves some trees
Spain – Leo Messi, from world player number one to brand.
Switzerland: iPhone is descriptive, no trade mark
Use of SKODA as a keyword: infringement issue "unclear", says Danish Court
"Global" infringer sent to jail
Switzerland: SINO is for China
(Almost) anyone v Iranian Tobacco Co was possible
On Little Black Horse in Shield on Red Background – Ferrari Successful as Milan Court Upholds Infringement Claims.
Spain - Court cancels a Spanish trade mark for "D10R".
Poland: bad faith in trade mark applications
VOLVO dissolves SOLVO
DPMA: IP Awareness and Enforcement conference - downloadable speakers' notes
Switzerland: not discriminating against MINARETT trade marks
Poland: reclaim the windows – the saga continues
Finland: The City of Turnip
Cheap, cheaper, Czech: CAC to offer UDRP proceedings for EUR 500
Genuine use of the earlier mark: COLORIS of 2003 v COLORIS of 1998
     + November (55)
     + October (49)
     + September (48)
     + August (39)
     + July (54)
     + June (54)
     + May (55)
     + April (54)
     + March (57)
     + February (48)
     + January (61)
+ 2008
+ 2007

 
 

Terms of Use: The material included on this site is provided for information purposes only, and we make no representations or warranties as to its accuracy. It does not represent legal advice. Before relying on this material, you should take care to verify its accuracy, taking professional advice as appropriate. [Please click here for the full Terms and Conditions of Use]

Copyright ©2008-2013 MARQUES Ltd and Individual Contributors